Orthopedic Surgeons Who Wear White Coat More Likely to Boost Patient’s Confidence

Patients feel more confident and better able to communicate with orthopedic surgeons who wore white coats, reports a new study.

Hospitalized patients express higher confidence in orthopedic surgeons wearing white coats, suggests a study in Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research® (CORR®), a publication of The Association of Bone and Joint Surgeons®. The journal is published in the Lippincott portfolio by Wolters Kluwer.

Has the White Coat Lost Its Meaning in the Hospitals?
Are doctors going to dump the white coat in favor of business suits? What does infection have to do with white coats?

‘Power of doctor’s white coat: Patients feel more confident when orthopedic surgeons wear a white coat.’

Tweet it Now

"We found patients had a moderate overall preference for physicians wearing a white coat, either over scrubs or business attire," according to the new research, led by John D. Jennings, MD, of Temple University School of Medicine, Philadelphia.

Surgeons in White Coats – Patients Express Preference for 'Archetypal Image'

Do clothes affect patients' perceptions of their orthopedic surgeon? To find out, Dr. Jennings and colleagues designed a study using photographs of a male and a female surgeon wearing five different outfits: a business suit, alone or with a while coat; surgical scrubs, alone or with a white coat; or casual attire, eg, jeans and a T-shirt.

Doctor's White Coat: Is It Covered in Germs?
Does doctor's white coat matter? Does it enhance patient's trust and confidence? A new study reveals that the coat does not matter to the patient and also has no impact on the patients outcome.

The research team showed the pictures, in random order, to 110 patients undergoing orthopedic surgery at their hospital. For each photo, patients rated their confidence in the surgeon, as well as their perceptions of his or her intelligence, trustworthiness, safety, skills, and the likely success of the surgery. Factors affecting the patients' ratings were assessed, including possible differences in perceptions of the female and male surgeons.

For both pictured surgeons, patients preferred a white coat over a business suit or scrubs, or surgical scrubs alone, compared to a business or casual attire. The ratings were similar for all attributes studied.

White-coat Syndrome | White-coat Hypertension Causes Symptoms Diagnosis Treatment
White-coat syndrome is an increase in blood pressure only in a clinical setting, due to a fear of doctors and needles. The symptoms include weight gain and increased risk of diabetes among others.

When asked to rank all five types of attire, patients expressed a "moderate overall preference" for surgeons wearing a white coat, over either a business suit or scrubs. Surgical scrubs alone were preferred over a business suit alone. Casual attire was consistently rated lowest.

The patients' expressed preferences were almost identical for the male and female surgeons. Although that was consistent with other recent studies, the researchers were pleasantly surprised to note the absence of gender bias, "given the known history of sexism in medicine."

Ban Indian Doctors, Medical Students from Wearing Long-Sleeved White Coats
To reduce the harm and cost that results from hospital acquired infections, doctors and medical students should be banned from wearing white coats.

Why does it matter what the surgeon is wearing? "Prior research suggests that physician attire has an important effect on patient perceptions, and can influence the patient-physician relationship," Dr. Jennings and colleagues write. Of the "countless factors" affecting this relationship, the physician's attire is one of the most easily studied and most easily changed.

"We found that the patient's perception of the physician's competence was affected by what the physician wore, with an overall preference for a white coat over either scrubs or professional attire," the researchers conclude. "We believe this is consistent with the archetypal image of a surgeon and is thus what patients expect from their treating physician."

In a CORR Insights® perspective piece, R. Justin Mistovich, MD, MBA, of Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, notes that the physician's "uniform" has traditionally met the demands of their work while also mitigating the spread of disease. He adds, "Physician attire must also meet patients' social expectations, which may be culture-bound, and may change over time."

Dr. Mistovich suggests further studies addressing not just perceptions and preferences, but also "the most logical and appropriate clothing choice in specific settings."

Source-Newswise