Brown University researchers have refuted claims of promiscuity and overlapping multiple sexual partners driving the HIV epidemic. Their study results suggest that there is not much scientific evidence to support the idea.
Thus, they have said that more research is needed to prove that the sexual practice of concurrency has accelerated the spread of HIV in Africa.
"People have just accepted at face value that this is the main thing that's driving the epidemic. But the evidence that concurrency is a major factor is very weak," said epidemiologist Mark Lurie, assistant professor community health and medicine.
They drew their conclusion by looking at previous studies that examined concurrency in any way.
And this, they say, is because HIV epidemics can't be explained by a single variable-a number of factors are more likely, with some factors more important in some geographic areas than others.
"The studies you need to prove causality don't exist. None of those studies have been done," said Lurie.
While the researchers don't dispute the notion that concurrent sexual relationships could "theoretically" play a major role driving HIV transmission through networks of people, but to prove this true, a number of research initiative are needed, they said.
And thus they have proposed improved methods for measuring both sexual behaviour and the duration or overlapping of sexual partnerships.
Other than that, a common definition of concurrency is also needed.
There is a need for longitudinal studies that measure both concurrency and incidence of HIV infection.
Without the added data, Lurie said, there is a risk that public policy-makers, development agencies, and aid organizations are spending too much money on campaigns against taking on overlapping multiple sexual partners when other causes may matter more.
"We are also worried about the unintended consequences of concurrency interventions. If you are giving a message that says 'Don't have concurrent partnerships,' then people can easily take away from that the message to have lots of partnerships as long as they don't overlap," said Lurie.
The study has been published in an upcoming issue of the journal AIDS and Behaviour.