Two legal experts argue on bmj.com today that informed consent should be obtained from competent patients before blood transfusions takes place.
Anne-Maree Farrell and Margaret Brazier, both from the
University of Manchester note that, in its recent report, the UK government's
Independent Advisory Committee on the Safety of Blood Tissues and Organs
(SaBTO) acknowledged that there is inconsistent practice in this area and that
there are concerns that patients are not given enough information about the
risks, benefits and alternatives to transfusion.
"Safe" Blood Transfusions can also Kill
A study by researchers in the US has found that trauma victims are twice as likely to die when given blood that has been stored for a longer time.
Advertisement
They argue that there is a question mark over the lack of legal requirement in the UK for consent for blood transfusions. They say: "National health policy and practice has put greater emphasis on patient involvement and choice about medical treatment in recent years. Against this background, there have been important legal developments regarding the information that should be disclosed to patients concerning risks associated with their medical treatment."
The authors state that there are serious infectious, as well
as non-infectious risks associated with blood transfusions and that it should
now be viewed as a legal requirement for patients to be informed about specific
risks posed by blood transfusions. This would work in the same way as they are
currently informed about risks associated with the medical treatment and/or
surgery they undergo.
![Blood Transfusion Should be a Last Resort for Hospitalized Cardiac Patients: Study]( "Blood Transfusion Should be a Last Resort for Hospitalized Cardiac Patients: Study")
A new study suggests that blood transfusions for hospitalized cardiac patients should be a last resort because of double the risk of infection and increase by four times the risk of death.
The current state of the law is such, they say, that the failure of healthcare professionals to advise patients of the specific risks of blood transfusion and to obtain their consent leaves them open to a claim of negligence or even battery in the event that the patient subsequently suffers harm as a result of the transfusion.
In conclusion, the authors argue that obtaining specific consent for blood transfusion in the UK is an important step towards "recognising the importance of patient autonomy in the context of decision making about medical treatment."
But an accompanying commentary questions whether the risks of transfusion are high enough to warrant specific informed consent. Ravi Gill, a consultant anaesthetist at Southampton University Hospital calculates that the rate of serious adverse events associated with blood transfusions is 0.019%.
A patient signing a standard NHS consent form will be giving their consent to a blood transfusion if required, he says. "I would hope that this was an informed choice and that the clinician as well as mentioning the possibility of a blood transfusion also mentions that transfusion itself has some risks, albeit small."
A common sense approach - explaining things clearly, tailoring what is said to what the patient seems to want, and checking understanding - is required for good medical practice, he concludes.
Source: BMJ
Blood Transfusion Should be a Last Resort for Hospitalized Cardiac Patients: Study
A new study suggests that blood transfusions for hospitalized cardiac patients should be a last resort because of double the risk of infection and increase by four times the risk of death.
Advertisement
The current state of the law is such, they say, that the failure of healthcare professionals to advise patients of the specific risks of blood transfusion and to obtain their consent leaves them open to a claim of negligence or even battery in the event that the patient subsequently suffers harm as a result of the transfusion.
In conclusion, the authors argue that obtaining specific consent for blood transfusion in the UK is an important step towards "recognising the importance of patient autonomy in the context of decision making about medical treatment."
But an accompanying commentary questions whether the risks of transfusion are high enough to warrant specific informed consent. Ravi Gill, a consultant anaesthetist at Southampton University Hospital calculates that the rate of serious adverse events associated with blood transfusions is 0.019%.
A patient signing a standard NHS consent form will be giving their consent to a blood transfusion if required, he says. "I would hope that this was an informed choice and that the clinician as well as mentioning the possibility of a blood transfusion also mentions that transfusion itself has some risks, albeit small."
A common sense approach - explaining things clearly, tailoring what is said to what the patient seems to want, and checking understanding - is required for good medical practice, he concludes.
Source: BMJ
Eight Jodhpur Kids Contract HIV After Blood Transfusion
Eight children in Jodhpur, Rajasthan, have been found to be suffering from thalassaemia and, have been declared HIV positive.
Advertisement
 Baby Survives 11 Blood Transfusions in Womb!Baby Jasmine Tanner needed as many as 11 blood transfusions in her mother's womb to live. | Advertisement
|
Advertisement
Recommended Reading
Latest General Health News
Direct coastal access may represent a viable route to public health promotion, but the relationships of coastal living are not strongest among lower-income groups.
New research by Tinnitus UK has found that over four million gardeners are putting their hearing capacity at risk this summer without using safety protection.
Mucus plugs could be targeted to help reduce fatalities from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.
The development of reliable curative therapies for multiple sclerosis could significantly reduce the economic burden of the disease on patients and wider society.
A genetic variant in a patient protected from autosomal dominant Alzheimer's disease (ADAD) suggests a role for RELN signaling in resilience to dementia.