About My Health Careers Internship MedBlogs Contact us

Value of Randomized Clinical Trials in Radiation Oncology Practice

by Bidita Debnath on June 1, 2013 at 11:45 PM
Font : A-A+

 Value of Randomized Clinical Trials in Radiation Oncology Practice

Physicians, insurers and cancer patients want to be sure that whatever therapy is recommended and provided to patients is based on evidence, preferably results from randomized clinical trials.

But are there enough clinical trials data to provide this level of confidence?


A University of North Carolina School of Medicine study says not necessarily. Radiation oncologists evaluated how often patients were seen in their clinic with medical decisions to be made that were not specifically addressed by randomized controlled trials.

They determined that in a group of 393 patients who were being treated with curative intent with multiple tumor types, 47 percent of all medical decisions were made without available or applicable randomized evidence to inform clinical decision making.

The study is the only known published study to evaluate the availability of evidence in a routine clinical setting for any medical specialty. It was published in the June issue of the journal Cancer.

"Randomized controlled trials are the lynchpin of clinical care, but the results are often not applicable to an individual patient, so all care cannot be provided entirely on the basis of those trials. We're not speaking against clinical trials. We're just pointing out their limitations in daily cancer care," said Joel Tepper, MD, senior author. Dr. Tepper is Hector McLean Distinguished Professor of Cancer Research, professor of radiation oncology and a member of UNC Lineberger Comprehensive Cancer Center.

Dr. Tepper said the study draws attention to several issues. "The potential negative consequences of evidence-based coverage policies may impede necessary and appropriate patient care. If the standard of adequate evidence in the form of randomized clinical trials are often not generalizable to patients, the appropriateness of using randomized data as the basis for coverage of every patient comes into question." Observational studies, trials conducted without randomization, are an option to inform decisions when randomized trials are not available.

"Additionally, we hope that our study results suggest that well-designed observational studies and alternative clinical trial designs may play a central role in the continued development of evidence for medical decision making in select patient groups," said Dr. Tepper. It also emphasizes the need for a robust clinical trial system that will generate more randomized trial data to inform clinical decision making.

"Our results also emphasize the importance of clinical judgment and experience in what we recommend to our patients. Tumor boards, when a patient's case is evaluated by a number of medical specialties, can also be extremely useful," he said.

The UNC group reviewed medical records of 393 patients evaluated for treatment in the UNC radiation oncology clinic. Patients with cancer of the breast (30 percent), head and neck (18 percent), and genitourinary (14 percent) were the most common tumor types included in the study. Patient medical decisions were classified as those with (Group 1) or without (Group 2) randomized clinical trials data. Group 1 was further divided into three groups based on the extent of fulfilling eligibility criteria for each randomized clinical trial: 1a) fulfilling all eligibility criteria; 1b) not fulfilling at least one minor eligibility criteria; and 1c) not fulfilling at least one major eligibility criteria. The availability of high level evidence varied by tumor type.

Source: Eurekalert

News A-Z
News Category
What's New on Medindia
Cervical Cancer Awareness Month 2022
Ultra-Low-Fat Diet
Goji Berries May Protect Against Age-Related Vision Loss
View all

Medindia Newsletters Subscribe to our Free Newsletters!
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

More News on:
Radiotherapy X-Ray Clinical Trials Clinical Trials - The Past and The Future Clinical Trials - Different Phases of the trial Chemotherapy Chemotherapy Drugs Placebo Effects: Rare Insights Radiation Hazards Acute Radiation Syndrome 

Recommended Reading
Oncology Patients Have New Options Thanks to Advancements in Fertility Preservation
It is a sad fact that people who have learned that they have cancer also are told that the ......
Showing Brain Tumour Eradication and Extended Survival: Study Published In Neuro-Oncology
Tocagen Inc. presented the company's investigational treatment for high grade glioma that wipes out ...
Increase In Patients' Travel Distance for Treatment Due To Urology-owned Radiation Oncology Self-referral
According to a study, men with prostate cancer in Texas may be driving more than three times ......
Treatment of Metastatic Triple-negative Breast Cancer Patients Guided By TGen-US Oncology
According to a study by genomic sequencing has revealed therapeutic drug targets for ......
Acute Radiation Syndrome
Acute radiation syndrome occurs when a person is exposed to a high dose of external penetrating radi...
‘Chemo’ means medicine or ‘drug’; ‘therapy’ means ‘treatment’. Chemotherapy refers to the use of cy...
Chemotherapy Drugs
Chemotherapy drugs perform like ‘magic bullets’ to destroy cancer cells in the body....
Clinical Trials
Clinical trials are experiments that yield useful information to clinicians if a particular treatmen...
Clinical Trials - Different Phases of the trial
Clinical trials serve as a vital component for improving the treatment of medical conditions as they...
Clinical Trials - The Past and The Future
Many of the drugs that are used today have been discovered by chance or often by mere serendipity...
Placebo Effects: Rare Insights
Placebo response is now generally well accepted. ‘Placebo response’ is the friend of the clinician a...
Radiation Hazards
Ionizing radiation can damage living tissue in the human body. It strips away electrons from atoms b...
A detailed account of radiation, its mode of action, side effects and dosage in the treatment of ......
Encyclopedia section of medindia gives a brief Overview of X-Ray  ...

Disclaimer - All information and content on this site are for information and educational purposes only. The information should not be used for either diagnosis or treatment or both for any health related problem or disease. Always seek the advice of a qualified physician for medical diagnosis and treatment. Full Disclaimer

© All Rights Reserved 1997 - 2022

This site uses cookies to deliver our services. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Use
open close
I have read and I do accept terms of use - Telemedicine

Advantage Medindia: FREE subscription for 'Personalised Health & Wellness website with consultation' (Value Rs.300/-)