Menu Calorie Counts Could Save Lives: England's Health Forecast

The simple act of requiring calorie information on menus in large food businesses in England could prevent approximately 730 cardiovascular deaths by 2041. If all businesses followed this practice, we could prevent even more deaths - around 9,200 over the same period, suggests the first modeled estimation of the impact of the policy published in The Lancet Public Health ().

Calorie Labels May Cut CVD Deaths in England

The modeling study suggests:

The first estimates of the impact of the current calorie labeling legislation in England, which applies only to large out-of-home food businesses, suggest the policy could prevent or postpone about 730 deaths from cardiovascular diseases between 2022 to 2041. 
Larger health benefits are estimated if the policy were to be implemented in all English out-of-home food businesses, with about 9,200 deaths from cardiovascular diseases potentially prevented over the next 20 years under this scenario. 
With no evidence of the policy contributing to health inequalities, authors say that extending calorie labeling to all out-of-home food businesses could maximize public health benefits as part of a broader England obesity strategy, alongside other policies to narrow the health inequality gap, such as the soft drinks levy.  
The study only looked at obesity rates and deaths from cardiovascular disease, and further research is needed on the cost-effectiveness and unintended negative effects of calorie labeling, such as its impact on eating disorders, to inform future policy decisions in addition to this study. .

In April 2022, as part of a national obesity strategy, the government implemented mandatory calorie labeling in out-of-home businesses in England with 250 or more employees that serve food. Similar legislation is being considered in Wales and Scotland and has been introduced in other countries, including the USA in 2019 and parts of Australia.

Previous studies from countries including the UK, USA, and Canada suggest menu calorie labeling leads to people ordering meals with approximately 47 fewer kcal and to businesses reducing the average calorie content of their meals by 15 kcal. This study is the first to model the impact of menu calorie labeling on obesity and deaths from cardiovascular disease in England and how the effect varies for different socioeconomic groups.

Use of Nutri-Score Label can Encourage Healthier Food Choices
Using Nutri-Score front-of-pack label can guide people towards healthier food choices, according to a new study.

‘Did you know? England's menu calorie labeling may prevent around 9,200 cardiovascular deaths over 20 years. #calorielabeling #heartdiseasedeaths #obesity #foodindustry #publichealth’

Tweet it Now

“Over one in four adults in England are currently living with obesity, with trends suggesting this is set to increase. Our research estimates that the current calorie labeling legislation will prevent hundreds of deaths from cardiovascular disease over the next 20 years, however, a much larger impact is possible if the government were more ambitious in its aims to tackle the obesity epidemic in England and extended the policy to all out-of-home food businesses,” says Prof Martin O'Flaherty, Professor in Epidemiology, University of Liverpool.

The authors modeled the estimated effect on obesity rates and cardiovascular disease deaths from 2022 to 2041 of the implementation of mandatory menu calorie labeling in England for two scenarios:

The actual policy deployment plan in England where only large out-of-home food businesses with 250 or more employees are mandated to have calorie information (this type of business makes up 18% of outlets).
The deployment of menu calorie labeling in every out-of-home food business in England.

These two scenarios were compared with a baseline scenario of if no policy was implemented.

Without any menu calorie labeling policy, the model estimates that cardiovascular disease trends will result in approximately 830,000 deaths by 2041 (within a range of 600,000–1,200,000). However, the current policy is estimated to prevent around 730 of these deaths (within a range of 430–1,300), and if the policy was extended to all out-of-home food businesses in England then about 9,200 deaths could be prevented (within a range of 5,500–16,000), almost 13 times more than the current policy.

Traffic Light-coded Food Labels Encourage People to Control Total Calorie Intake
Using traffic light-coded food labels, which reveal the amount of fat, salt and sugar an item contains, helps people eat right and maintain healthy weight.

The baseline scenario assumed the obesity prevalence in England in 2041 would be 27%. The model estimated that the current policy would reduce obesity prevalence by 0.31 (within a range of 0.10–0.35) percentage points in the next 20 years, but full implementation of the policy would reduce obesity prevalence by 2.65 percentage points (within a range of 1.97–3.24).

Calorie Labeling Impact: Predicting Fewer CVD Fatalities

The model suggests that menu calorie labeling does not widen inequalities in obesity prevalence or cardiovascular disease mortality between different socioeconomic groups, based on existing evidence of equivalent policy effects across socioeconomic groups.

“Previous studies have suggested that calorie labeling on menus has a double effect – it allows customers to make informed decisions and choose options with fewer calories whilst also encouraging companies to reduce the calories in their food.

Front-of-Package Food Labels Encourage Healthier Eating: Study
Nutrition labels on front of food packaging can promote healthier food choices, reports a new study.

The large out-of-home food businesses represent a small portion of all out-of-home food businesses in England, and as more than half of them already provided calorie information on their menus before the introduction of this legislation in 2022 [1], the policy in its current form only impacts a small proportion of all out-of-home food businesses in England,” says Dr Zoe Colombet, Lecturer in Epidemiology and Public Health, University of Liverpool.

She continues, “Our results suggest expanding calorie labeling on menus to all English out-of-home food businesses could play an important part in future government strategies to support people in making healthier choices to tackle obesity. However, one policy alone cannot solve England’s obesity crisis. We encourage the government to continue with and strengthen, the England obesity strategy with a wide range of policies, such as calorie labeling, tackling junk food marketing, and the soft drinks industry levy, which will both reduce obesity and narrow the shocking health inequalities gap in our society,”

Food Labels Nudge Diners to Make Healthier Food Choices: Cornell Study
Putting calories and fat content on the label on various foods purchased produces a 7% reduction of mean total calories and total fat purchased per week.

The authors caution that their study contains some limitations, including that the data on calorie reductions associated with the policy within the model was taken from US studies, which may not be transferable to the English population. They also highlight that the study only modeled adult obesity, so is unable to examine the impact on childhood obesity.

Notably, modeling studies include a number of assumptions that can influence the findings, in this case for instance the authors assumed the amounts of energy consumed would not differ by the size of business, and assumed no major changes to BMI prevalence over the next 20 years.

Additionally, there are several other areas of policy impact that this study did not investigate. “Our study only looks at the impact of the policy on obesity prevalence and cardiovascular disease in adults. There may be other benefits that can be difficult to quantify, such as increasing consumer’s knowledge and giving them the opportunity to make informed choices when eating out.

Policymakers must consider multiple factors when making decisions and future research is required about the cost-effectiveness of the policy, the impact on consumers and businesses, as well as the potential unintended negative consequences such as those on eating disorders,” says Prof Eric Robinson, Professor of Psychology, University of Liverpool.

Reference:

Effect of calorie labelling in the out-of-home food sector on adult obesity prevalence, cardiovascular mortality, and social inequalities in England: a modelling study - (https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpub/article/PIIS2468-2667(23)00326-2/fulltext)

Source-Eurekalert