Insurance Status Linked to Differences in Patient Safety and Quality of Care

by Bidita Debnath on February 28, 2015 at 10:29 PM
Font : A-A+

 Insurance Status Linked to Differences in Patient Safety and Quality of Care

Patients that are on Medicaid or uninsured have higher rates of reportable patient safety and quality of care issues during hospitalization for brain tumors, finds a study.

The study got published in the March issue of Neurosurgery, official journal of the Congress of Neurological Surgeons. The journal is published by Wolters Kluwer.


Not having private insurance is associated with higher rates of patient safety issues (PSIs) and hospital-acquired conditions (HACs)—leading to longer hospital stays and worse patient outcomes, according to the study by Dr. Kristopher G. Hooten and colleagues of University of Florida, Gainesville. Especially with reporting of these quality metrics under health care reform, the authors call for efforts to address disparities in quality of care for vulnerable patient populations.

Insurance Status Linked to Patient Safety and Quality of Care

Using a nationwide hospital care database, the researchers analyzed nearly 550,000 patients with brain tumors receiving hospital care between 2002 and 2011. About 44 percent of patients were on Medicare and 41 percent had private insurance. The remaining 15 percent were classified as Medicaid or "self-pay" (uninsured) patients.

Overall rates of reportable PSIs and HACs were highest for Medicare patients: 22.8 and 4.0 percent, respectively. Further analysis of the effects of insurance status excluded the Medicare group—because it was restricted to older adults, it wasn't comparable to the other groups.

The Medicaid/self-pay patients had more reportable quality problems than the privately insured patients. Patient safety issues were reported for 20.6 percent of Medicaid/self-pay patients, compared to 8.6 percent for those with private insurance. Hospital-acquired conditions were reported for 2.2 percent of the Medicaid/self-pay group versus 1.9 percent of the privately insured group.

There were several important differences in patient characteristics between groups—including the fact that Medicaid/self-pay patients had more accompanying medical problems and were more likely to be hospitalized on an emergency basis, compared to those with private insurance.

After adjustment for patient factors, the differences by insurance status remained significant. The increased rates of PSIs and HACs in the Medicaid/self-pay group were associated with more time in the hospital and an increased risk of poor outcomes, including in-hospital death.

Differences Explained by Adjustment for Patient and Hospital Factors

Medicaid/self-pay patients were also more likely to be treated at government-funded and teaching hospitals, and the percentage of such patients was highest in Southern states. Controlling for hospital factors, in addition to patient factors, explained the effects of insurance status on PSIs and HACs.

That suggests that the higher rates of quality problems aren't explained by insurance status itself, but rather by a complex mix of related factors—including differences in access to health care and prehospital treatment. Even though teaching hospitals treated more Medicaid/self-pay patients, their rates of PSIs and HACs were no higher than at non-teaching hospitals.

Under the Affordable Care Act, hospitals' reimbursement is tied to their performance on measures including PSIs and HACs. The new study shows that for patients with brain tumors, rates of reportable patient safety and care quality problems are higher for Medicaid and underinsured patients, and lead to worse patient outcomes. Similar disparities related to insurance status have been found in other groups of patients, such as those undergoing vascular or colorectal cancer surgery.

Further study is needed to evaluate possible measures to address HACs and PSIs in brain tumor patients—focusing on common events such as falls, pressure ulcers, and postoperative respiratory failure. Dr. Hooten and colleagues conclude, "With the implementation of the Patient Safety and Affordable Care Act, the cause of these factors should be studied prospectively to begin the process of improving quality metrics in vulnerable patient populations."

Source: Medindia

News A-Z
News Category
What's New on Medindia
Sedentary Behavior Precipitates Night-Time Hot Flashes
World Alzheimer's Day 2021 - 'Know Dementia, Know Alzheimer's
View all

Medindia Newsletters Subscribe to our Free Newsletters!
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

More News on:
Star Health and Allied Insurance ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Limited Health Insurance - Ombudsman Health Insurance - Basics New India Assurance Policies Awareness about Healthcare Insurance in India Premium Calculation by Health Insurance Companies Fraudulent Health Insurance Claims Key Procedures for Filing a Healthcare Insurance Claim Latest on The New India Assurance Company Ltd 

Recommended Reading
Star Health and Allied Insurance
Star Health & Allied Insurance offers a convenient insurance for the corporate people when they ......
Cholamandalam Health Insurance Policies
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company (Chola MS) a joint venture of Murugappa Group & Mitsui .....
Tata AIG General Insurance Company Ltd
Tata AIG General Insurance Company Limited is a joint venture company between the Tata Group and ......
Student Health Insurance Options
When students study abroad, they are away from their family and on their own, they need the ......
Awareness about Healthcare Insurance in India
A basic awareness about Indian health insurance for any layman for quick reference presented in a cr...
Fraudulent Health Insurance Claims
To educate the public regarding hazards of committing fraud in healthcare insurance claims and its i...
Health Insurance - Basics
Health insurance guarantees payments to a person in the event of sickness or injury.and works as pr...
Health Insurance - Ombudsman
Insurance Ombudsman institutions work for the purpose of quick disposal of the grievances of the ins...
ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Limited
Major health care plans from the ICICI Lombard include complete health insurance ihealth plan, perso...
Key Procedures for Filing a Healthcare Insurance Claim
keep yourself well informed about the claim process and avoid frustration of your claim getting ......
New India Assurance Policies
The existing Mediclaim and Health Plus Medical expenses policies have been discontinued and Mediclai...
Premium Calculation by Health Insurance Companies
This article gives an insight as to how healthcare insurance policy premiums are collected by Insura...

Disclaimer - All information and content on this site are for information and educational purposes only. The information should not be used for either diagnosis or treatment or both for any health related problem or disease. Always seek the advice of a qualified physician for medical diagnosis and treatment. Full Disclaimer

© All Rights Reserved 1997 - 2021

This site uses cookies to deliver our services. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Use