Health Care Has The Potential To Include Mandated Rather Than Recommended Treatment Guidelines

by Aruna on  August 07, 2009 at 5:15 PM Health Insurance News
  •   Print
  •   Share
  •   Comments
  •  Text 
Health Care Has The Potential To Include Mandated Rather Than Recommended Treatment Guidelines
Dr. Pamela Hartzband, MD, and Dr. Jerome Groopman, MD, caution that health care reform carries with it the potential to create a clash between two recent trends in medicine.

Writing in the Aug. 6 edition of the New England Journal of Medicine, they warn that the trends like the humanism movement that focuses on individual values, goals and preferences, and the move toward evidence-based practice, data and guidelines are standardized therapies and procedures.

As President Obama and Congress weigh changes in the nation's health care system they must avoid creating a system where physicians are financially motivated to pressure patients into mandated treatments that conflict with their values and needs, two Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center physicians warn.

In particular, they raise concern over the potential to include mandated rather than recommended treatment guidelines as part of Medicare reforms. Mandated treatments have been proposed as part of "value-based purchasing" and "pay for performance."

"These guidelines will have the unintended consequence of misaligning the goals of doctors and patients," they write. "Physicians will face a new conflict-of-interest: they will be financially motivated to pressure patients into accepting a mandated treatment regardless of whether it is compatible with their values or preferences or to avoid caring for patients who refuse the mandated treatment."

Not only are there serious ethical concerns about mandated guidelines, but also significant scientific limitations to this approach to treatment. "Because guidelines are derived from clinical studies carried out in selected groups of patients and their statistical conclusions are based on study populations, they may not apply to an individual patient, especially if he or she has coexisting conditions."

Page 1 Page 1 | 2  Next
 Email Email   RSS Feeds RSS Feeds   Print this page Print   Save this page Save   Link Link   Syndicate Syndicate   Comments Comments   Bookmark and Share
 
Comment & Contribute
Comments should be on the topic and should not be abusive. Comments are normally moderated and are reviewed after they are posted.
* Your comment can be maximum of 2500 characters

Notify me when reply is posted
I agree to the terms and conditions
  
If you have a question about health related issues, you can now post it in our Ask An Expert section on our community website Medwonders.com and get answers from our panel of experts.
X
  • Health News Index
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
News Archive
Date :
Category :
Keyword :
  • News Quick Links
News Central Health Watch
Latest Health News Health In Focus
News Category (500+) Breaking Health News
Popular News Celebrating Life
Health News and Press Release Medindia - Exclusive
News Photo Gallery India Special
News Video Gallery Lifestyle and Wellness
News From Other Resources
News Categories:  
Diabetes Health Center

Health Insurance Related News

» Report: A Lot of Americans Have No Access to Health Care » Greece Faces Humanitarian Crisis as Health Care Access Declines in EU, Doctors Group Warns
» HCCI Report Says Rising Prices for Care Responsible for Increased Healthcare Costs for Privately Insured Americans » Treatment in ED is Based on Children's Insurance Status
» US Spends Most on Healthcare Without Providing Superior Care » South Carolina’s Taxpayers Will Not Have to Pay for Abortions in Rape Cases
» Companies Try to Avoid Steep Health Insurance Bills by Rewarding Employees For Healthy Lifestyles » MD247.com to Knock Out Health Insurance Companies Through Telemedicine
Read More >>