About Careers MedBlog Contact us

Women Should Make Their Own Decision About Breast Screening

by Medindia Content Team on October 13, 2007 at 11:07 AM
Font : A-A+

Women Should Make Their Own Decision About Breast Screening

Women in their 40s should be encouraged to decide whether breast screening is right for them, rather than being told what to do, argue two US experts in this week's BMJ.

In April 2007, the American College of Physicians issued new guidelines on screening mammography for women aged 40-49. Rather than calling for universal screening, they recommend that women make an informed decision after learning about the benefits and harms of mammography.


Reaction to these guidelines was muted, write authors Lisa Schwartz and Steven Woloshin, suggesting that the public and profession increasingly accept that cancer screening has both benefits and harms.

Perhaps we are finally moving beyond the debate about what women should do and are ready to focus on how to help women make the best decision for themselves, they say.

But no right choice exists, they explain, because screening has mixed effects - some women will benefit (by avoiding death from breast cancer) but others will be harmed by unnecessary treatment. So the next step is to ensure that women understand what is likely to happen if they do or do not undergo screening.

The data shows that in the US, for every 1000 women screened over the next 10 years less than one life will be "saved" for younger women and about three lives will be saved for older women.

But screening has several harms, say the authors. False positives - abnormalities detected at mammography that often cause women to undergo repeat testing (or perhaps biopsy) to rule out cancer - are the most familiar and can cause short term anxiety, inconvenience, and sometimes unnecessary biopsies. But they think that overdiagnosis is the most important harm of screening.

Overdiagnosis is the detection of lesions that meet the pathological criteria for cancer but would not progress to cause symptoms or death, they explain. Women who are overdiagnosed can only be harmed by treatment - they cannot benefit because no treatment was needed. Harms include disfiguring surgery, side effects of chemotherapy or hormonal therapy (such as nausea, fatigue, and hair loss), and injury from radiation.

Calculating the chance of overdiagnosis is challenging, but the authors estimate that, for every 1000 women screened over the next 10 years, up to five aged 40-49 and up to nine aged 50 and over may be affected.

Once informed about the possibility of overdiagnosis, most women say they would factor it into their decision about screening.

The new guideline is an improvement because it integrates informed decision making into policy recommendations, say the authors. Rather than telling women what they should do, policy makers should encourage women to make a decision that is right for them, they conclude.

Source: BMJ


Recommended Reading

Latest Women Health News

 Finding the Best Tool for Assessing Osteoporosis Fracture Risk After Menopause
The commonly used Fracture Risk Assessment Tool (FRAX) is not useful for shared clinical decision-making regarding osteoporosis screening in younger postmenopausal women.
 Pregnancy Complications Linked to Woman's Stroke Risk at Midlife
Researchers hypothesized that adverse pregnancy outcomes (APO) are associated with younger age at first stroke, with a stronger relationship in those with >1 pregnancy with APO.
Escaping the Cycle of Perfection: Redefining Women's Roles!
Women grapple with the risk of mental illnesses as immense challenge of constantly striving for perfection and balancing multiple roles takes a toll.
Breaking the Myth of Animal Product Dependency for Lactating Mothers
Irrespective of dietary preferences, lactating mothers maintain similar concentrations of nutrients in their breast milk, when comparing vegan and omnivorous diets.
Weekend Sleep: How to Reduce Your Risk of Hyperuric Activity
Among postmenopausal women, increased levels of serum uric acid levels are linked to heart diseases, whereas good-quality sleep has proven health benefits.
View All
This site uses cookies to deliver our services.By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Use  Ok, Got it. Close

Women Should Make Their Own Decision About Breast Screening Personalised Printable Document (PDF)

Please complete this form and we'll send you a personalised information that is requested

You may use this for your own reference or forward it to your friends.

Please use the information prudently. If you are not a medical doctor please remember to consult your healthcare provider as this information is not a substitute for professional advice.

Name *

Email Address *

Country *

Areas of Interests