Should NHS Training Posts Be Reserved for UK Graduates?

by Venkatraman on September 22, 2007 at 12:01 PM
Should NHS Training Posts Be Reserved for UK Graduates?

After many young doctors failed to get NHS jobs this summer, two experts in this week's BMJ debate whether training posts should be reserved for UK graduates.

Society has a moral obligation to ensure that young people who successfully complete a demanding primary medical course have the opportunity to complete their training and enter medical practice, argues Edward Byrne, Dean at the Faculty of Biomedical Sciences, University College London.


He acknowledges that we live in a global world and free exchange of expertise is clearly desirable. However, this needs to be balanced against the training needs of UK graduates. One possible solution, he says, would be to encourage a period of work in other countries towards the end of specialty or family medicine training.

Medical training in the UK is among the best in the world and it is appropriate that a country with the wealth and stature of the United Kingdom cover its medical workforce needs without drawing doctors from less well advantaged countries in Europe or elsewhere, he writes.

If the UK can contribute a relatively small number of fully trained doctors to work in other countries, that would be a useful contribution to international health. But, he argues, a failure to provide training opportunities for the great majority of UK graduates and enable them to enter practice would represent a waste of human potential and a failure of care for young doctors.

Restricting access would damage the profession, argues Edwin Borman, Consultant Anaesthetist at Coventry and Warwickshire NHS Trust and Chairman of the BMA's International Committee.

For most of the lifespan of the NHS, the UK has had an implicit policy to rely on international medical graduates to "top up" the number of UK graduates, he writes. Currently, 36% of doctors registered to practise in the NHS qualified abroad.

It is to the credit of the medical profession that during the crisis of the medical training application service (MTAS), all eligible applicants have been treated equally and posts have been allocated according to merit, he says.

The good name of the medical profession in the UK already has been damaged by the Home Office which introduced changes, without notice, to the immigration rules. It would be a tragedy for the profession itself to sully its reputation by abandoning the principle of solidarity that goes back as far as the Hippocratic Oath.

And he suggests that the blame for the chaos that is MTAS should be placed with those in the Department of Health who decided that medical staffing no longer needed to be planned centrally. Instead, he argues that training places should be limited to numbers that reflect the projected future need for consultants and general practice principals.

The anger of those caught up in the MTAS debacle is expressed in a personal view by Parashkev Nachev, a clinical research fellow at Imperial College London. He argues that the system has damaged professional standards and blames the royal colleges for "failing to act when there was still time to do so."

Source: BMJ
Font : A-A+



Latest General Health News

Americans Struggle to Keep Up Healthy Habits in Holiday Season
Most Americans confess that due to constant flurry of activity during the holiday season, it is difficult to eat nutritiously, exercise, and get enough sleep.
Depression, Constipation & Urinary Tract Infection: Early Signs of Multiple Sclerosis
People who suffer from depression, constipation, and urinary tract infections are more likely to get multiple sclerosis(MS) five years before MS diagnosis.
Antibiotic Misuse Can Cause Kidney Stones & Infection
Seeking internet help for an incomplete antibiotic course resulted in kidney stone formation and urinary tract infection in a young woman.
Brain Care Score Tracks Dementia & Stroke Risks
The Brain Care Score is a tool to evaluate brain health and reduce the risk of brain disorders including dementia and stroke.
First Human Case of Rare Swine Flu Strain H1N2 Found in UK
Swine influenza A viruses, including subtypes H1N1, H1N2, and H3N2, are prominent among pigs and sporadically transmit to humans.
View All
This site uses cookies to deliver our services.By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Use  Ok, Got it. Close

Should NHS Training Posts Be Reserved for UK Graduates? Personalised Printable Document (PDF)

Please complete this form and we'll send you a personalised information that is requested

You may use this for your own reference or forward it to your friends.

Please use the information prudently. If you are not a medical doctor please remember to consult your healthcare provider as this information is not a substitute for professional advice.

Name *

Email Address *

Country *

Areas of Interests