About My Health Careers Internship MedBlogs Contact us

Indian Court seeks Clearer Advice on Application for Abortion from 25-week Pregnant Woman

by Gopalan on August 2, 2008 at 12:55 PM
Font : A-A+

Indian Court seeks Clearer Advice on Application for Abortion from 25-week Pregnant Woman

The Bombay High Court in western India on Friday asked a panel of doctors to tender clearer advice on the application for abortion from 25-week pregnant woman. An earlier report was found contradictory.

Niketa and Haresh Mehta, both in their early thirties, along with their doctor Nikhil Datar had moved the High Court seeking permission to abort the couple's first child as it had a congenital heart disease.


The JJ hospital panel stated, "Sonography report shows that the foetus has a congental complete heart block."

The consensus of the panel was that "there are very fair chances that the child will be born incapacitated and handicapped to survive".

Still, curiously, the J J Hospital committee added that "the findings were not significant to warrant an abortion."

In the circumstances Division Bench of Justices P B Majumdar and Amjad Sayed called on the panel to give the court a "positive and firm" report whether the abortion should be allowed owing to a risk to the foetus.

The court said, "Looking into the urgency of the matter, the report should be in by Monday morning."

The couple's contention is that that the unborn child will suffer critical problems even with a permanent pacemaker. The US and the UK allow medical termination of pregnancy up to the 24th week, they note

This is the city's first legal challenge to the country's 37-year-old law preventing abortion beyond 20 weeks unless the pregnancy constitutes a health risk for the mother.

"There is not only a heart blockage that will require a permanent pace-maker but the baby's right and left ventricles are also interchanged,'' Haresh said, quoting doctors.

"We were told our decision to opt for an abortion was correct in the circumstances. But the law prevents us from doing it legally,'' Mehta said from his Nariman Point office.

"We agonised over this a lot as this is our first child. But then there is no guarantee we will be there tomorrow. Life today has become so tenuous. Who will look after our child if and when we are not there?'' he asked.

The Mehtas had to undergo a whole series of tests at the J J Hospital. "It was a long day from 11 am to 6.30 pm with no meal. The hospital did not have the latest machines and we were orally told after a sonography that there was only a heart blockage,'' said Niketa. Past 25 weeks into the pregnancy, she was exhausted by the end of the ordeal Wednesday.

One of their relations has a child with a serious congenital defect, and the Mehtas have seen their trauma. "We want a child and we will be equally happy with a boy or a girl but the child can't be made to suffer through life,'' Haresh stressed.

The petition filed by Haresh and Niketa Mehta is the first example of someone thinking of the quality of life of an unborn foetus, feels their lawyer, Amit Karkhanis. "Abortion laws have only focussed on the health of the pregnant woman,'' he noted.

Women's rights lawyer Flavia Agnes felt abortion should be permitted if there was a threat to the foetus's health. Women often faced the brunt of bringing up children with serious congenital abnormalities, she noted, adding: "I have seen women suffer and marriages break down because the father and his family are not ready to accept the child. The women become the primary caretaker of the child and many mothers go through acute depression. The law needs to be amended.''

But the Mehtas will have to contend with the likes of the Mumbai archbishop Cardinal Oswald Gracias who says "abortion is a horrendous evil and is a threat to human dignity because it directly attacks life itself."

Source: Medindia

News A-Z
News Category
What's New on Medindia
Top 7 Benefits of Good Oral Hygiene
Healthy and Safer Thanksgiving 2021
Long-Term Glycemic Control - A Better Measure of COVID-19 Severity
View all

Medindia Newsletters Subscribe to our Free Newsletters!
Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

More News on:
Ectopic Pregnancy Dilatation and Curettage Breech Presentation and Delivery Pregnancy and Complications Anemia in Pregnancy Iron & Folate Deficiency Anemia In Pregnancy Diet for Anemia in Pregnancy The Magic Feeling of Being A Mother Abortion Nocturnal Leg Cramps 

Recommended Reading
High Risk Pregnancy Group Calculator
Medindia offers you a useful calculator to find out if you fall under the high risk pregnant group. ...
Council of Europe Calls for Safe and Legal Abortion for All
The Council of Europe on Wednesday called for women throughout its 47 member states to be ......
Congenital Heart Disease – Septal Defects - Faqs
Frequently asked questions about septal defects or holes in the heart....
Abortion is one of the most controversial topics in medicine. Legalization of abortion in several co...
Anemia in Pregnancy
Anemia is the commonest blood disorder that may occur in pregnancy and is usually due to low iron or...
Breech Presentation and Delivery
Breech birth or presentation is delivery of the fetus in a bottom or foot-first position. Causes of ...
Diet for Anemia in Pregnancy
A modified diet rich in Folate, Vitamin B12 and Iron is essential for the rapid rise in hemoglobin ....
Ectopic Pregnancy
When the fertilization of the ovum occurs in a place other than the uterus, the condition is called ...
Iron & Folate Deficiency Anemia In Pregnancy
About 95% of the anemia cases are due to iron deficiency....
Nocturnal Leg Cramps
Nocturnal leg cramps are painful muscle contractions, which occur in the calf, foot or thigh muscles...
Pregnancy and Complications
In-depth guide for expecting mothers to overcome health complications related to early or late pregn...
The Magic Feeling of Being A Mother
Selecting the doctor who will help you in your pregnancy is a very personal decision. ...

Disclaimer - All information and content on this site are for information and educational purposes only. The information should not be used for either diagnosis or treatment or both for any health related problem or disease. Always seek the advice of a qualified physician for medical diagnosis and treatment. Full Disclaimer

© All Rights Reserved 1997 - 2021

This site uses cookies to deliver our services. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Use