Merciless Lathi Charge of our Meritorious Medicos

by Medindia Content Team on  May 14, 2006 at 2:59 PM Health Watch
RSS Email Print This Page Comment bookmark
Font : A-A+

The widespread protest by medical students across the country shows the anguish and the strong undercurrent that prevails in the country against the government's policy for reservations for OBC in professional course be it medical colleges, IITs or IIMs.
Merciless Lathi Charge of our Meritorious Medicos
Merciless Lathi Charge of our Meritorious Medicos

The protests are gaining momentum and now besides the medicos the IIT students also have decided to join the agitation. What the government and the administration has to remember is that; we are dealing with a highly meritorious class of youth of our country. They are the best and perhaps the cream of the cream of our society. To see them being mercilessly beaten for their peaceful protests by our notorious policemen invokes in us an anguish and anger. History repeats itself from the time of Gandhiji's Satyagrahis to todays - Medha Patekar's Narmada Andolan volunteers. In India the administration has always failed to learn how to deal with peaceful protests.

Show Full Article

The politicians of our country have repeatedly played politics with caste, creed and religion. They will continue to use this card to their advantage. However the government should not treat this lightly. Protests can take a nasty turn and the student force and resentment can have widespread implication for the future of any government in this country. There are ample examples of this in the past - be it Bihar or Assam.

In India the problem is highly complex. The current political agenda is powered by coalition Government with regional powers ruling most of the decision making or more often decision postponement. There is seldom a unison view on any of the important issues and often the government continues to drag and postpone such issues. When things get out of hand; the government legislature has often shifted the responsibility of decision making to the Supreme Court. The constitution framework provides the government a very broad platform to operate from and many of the issues that are tossed to the Supreme Court do not have require any clarification as they have no constitutional ambiguities.

Where does this agitation go from here? So far there has been no serious attempts for a dialogue on this issue by the Government. The question we need to ask is can the minorities be helped by other means. Can there be a fair system for all. A high profile committee led by Sam Pitaroda (appointed by the Prime Minister) also felt that this policy will hinder the growth of the country; however they added that the same can be achieved by other means and a dialogue is required. Merit in this country should prevail. More so in professional colleges; especially if the country wishes to continue to enjoy this path of progress. There is no place for politics in this area. This argument of equal opportunity to OBC is weak in today's context. Economical status is what decides the class in today's society and it is not CASTE - in this or any other country in the world today. We hope the politicians are listening.

Post a Comment

Comments should be on the topic and should not be abusive. The editorial team reserves the right to review and moderate the comments posted on the site.
Notify me when reply is posted
I agree to the terms and conditions

Merit is an alien concept to bharatiya culture. It was imported from the west and it probably makes sense in a homogenous society. But India is not and some people are disadvantaged due to two thousand years of caste based oppression. It takes time for the dormant genes to get back to full form and only reservations can make them happen. We are already seeing second generation of reservation beneficiaries giving these so called 'meritorious' FCs a run for their money...


India is all for Indians, it is about time our educational institutions represent the social fabric of the country. A few castes have been having it good for too long, hogging all the seats for themselves. The time has come for a change...If FCs don't want to share this country's resources with everyone, let them go to hell.


It is ridiculous to equate medical students with rioters but that is what the police seem to have done. I think it is time all doctors took a stand on this issue

A matter of great shame. The polce always seem to overdo in India. They are as merciless as the Britishers who caned our Satyagrahis. well written report from medindia

News A - Z



Medindia Newsletters

Subscribe to our Free Newsletters!

Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Stay Connected

  • Available on the Android Market
  • Available on the App Store

News Category

News Archive