Update on Prostate Cancer Screening Guidelines - The Controversy

by Mita Majumdar on  July 2, 2012 at 12:07 PM Health In Focus
RSS Email Print This Page Comment bookmark
Font : A-A+

The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) in their update on prostate cancer screening guidelines recommended against prostate specific antigen (PSA) based screening for men who are older than 50 years of age and who do not have symptoms of prostate cancer.
Update on Prostate Cancer Screening Guidelines - The Controversy
Update on Prostate Cancer Screening Guidelines - The Controversy

Prostate cancer starts in the prostate gland cells and grows slowly in most cases but sometimes it can grow and spread quickly. A man has about one in six chances of being diagnosed and one out of thirty three chances of dying because of this disease, according to the CDC statistics.

Prostate cancer is generally screened with the help of two tests, namely, the DRE or the digital rectal examination wherein the examiner inserts a gloved finger into the rectum and feels the prostate for size and irregular or abnormally firm areas; and the PSA test wherein a small amount of blood is drawn from the arm of the patient to check if the PSA level is normal (4 ng/mL or less). However, PSA levels can also be affected by certain medical procedures, and enlarged prostate or a prostate infection.

Scientific evidence shows that finding and treating a prostate cancer early increases the effectiveness of treatment and can thus save lives. Studies also recommended the screenings to be done annually beginning at the age of 50.

The USPSTF review, however, found no evidence that PSA based screening can save lives. Over and above, the treatment risks for most men far outweigh the benefits of PSA screening. This is because, the Task Force reasoned, a PSA test cannot differentiate between aggressive and non-aggressive cancers, which may result in many men undergoing needless surgery and radiation that expose them to significant side effects. According to the Task Force update, 'Adequate evidence shows that nearly 90 percent of men with PSA-detected prostate cancer undergo early treatment with surgery, radiation, or androgen deprivation therapy. Adequate evidence also shows that up to 5 in 1,000 men will die within 1 month of prostate cancer surgery and between 10 and 70 men will have serious complications but survive. Radiotherapy and surgery result in adverse effects, including urinary incontinence and erectile dysfunction in at least 200 to 300 of 1,000 men treated with these therapies. Radiotherapy is also associated with bowel dysfunction'. They used the terms 'over-diagnosis' or 'pseudo-disease' to describe these situations.

The clinical studies under the USPSTF review do not show a significant reduction in deaths from prostate cancer among men who had the PSA test compared with those who did not.

Prostate cancer is the second most common cancer affecting around a million men globally, according to the World Cancer Research Fund International. And along with the USPSTF and CDC, this organization too feels that increase in the prostate cancer incidence has been largely due to the increased availability of screening for PSA in men without symptoms of the disease. They believe the PSA test detects many prostate cancers that are small and /or would otherwise remained unrecognized and which may or may not develop further into higher stage disease.

Some medical and health institutes, however, do not agree with the recommendation of USPSTF. For example, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, recommends the following screening guidelines -

1. 'All men should receive a PSA test at age 45. For these men with a:

a) PSA greater than or equal to 3 ng / mL: Consider biopsy

b) PSA greater than 1 but less than 3 ng / mL: Return for PSA every two years

c) PSA from 0.65 to 1 ng / mL: Return for PSA at age 50

d) PSA less than 0.65 ng / mL: Return for PSA at age 55

2. For men aged 45 to 59 with a:

a) PSA greater than or equal to 3 ng / mL: Consider biopsy

b) PSA greater than 1 but less than 3 ng / mL: Return for PSA every two years

c) PSA from 0.65 to 1 ng / mL: Return for PSA in five years, or age 60 if age > 55

d) PSA less than 0.65 ng / mL: Return for PSA at age 60

3. For men aged 60 to 70 with a:

a) PSA greater than or equal to 3 ng / mL: Consider biopsy

b) PSA greater than 1 but less than 3 ng / mL: Return for PSA every two years

c) PSA less than or equal to 1 ng / mL: No further screening

4. For men aged 71 or older:

a) No further screening'

Similarly, the American Urological Association (AUA) issued a statement that 'an appropriately interpreted PSA test provides important information concerning the diagnosis, pretreatment staging or risk assessment, and monitoring of prostate cancer patients'. Once prostate cancer is diagnosed the patient needs to discuss with his doctor regarding the course of action.

That a patient should consult his physician, consider the risks and benefits, and make an informed decision about whether to be screened for prostate cancer, has also been suggested by the American Cancer Society.

'Understanding the issues involved with prostate cancer screening and the steps that follow a PSA test is knowledge that all men should have when making the decision to be screened. Elevated PSA levels do not always mean a man has cancer; other benign (non cancerous) prostate problems can also raise a man's PSA level. And many men with low PSAs do have prostate cancer', says Dr Michael J. Barry, President, Foundation for Informed Medical Decision Making. 

"It may be a simple test but it's not a simple decision," says Dr. Karnes, urologist from the Mayo Clinic. "A PSA test is something you should decide after discussing it with your doctor, considering your risk factors and weighing your personal preferences."

The medical experts do not yet know what causes prostate cancer or how to prevent this cancer. But what they do know is that certain lifestyle changes such as not smoking, switching to a healthy diet and being physically active will keep the body healthy and possibly reduce the chances of advanced prostate cancer. So, one needs to make an informed decision based on the suggestion of their doctor.



References :

1. http://www.cdc.gov/cancer/prostate/pdf/prosguide.pdf

2. http://www.mskcc.org/cancer-care/screening-guidelines/screening-guidelines-prostate

3. http://hosted.verticalresponse.com/947263/fa554eab10/1501562419/8580406966/

Source: Medindia

Post a Comment

Comments should be on the topic and should not be abusive. The editorial team reserves the right to review and moderate the comments posted on the site.
Notify me when reply is posted
I agree to the terms and conditions

More News on:

Prostate Cancer Cancer and Homeopathy Trans-Urethral Resection of the Prostate Prostate Cancer Facts Cancer Facts Cancer Tattoos A Body Art Prostate Cancer: Treatment Options Prostate Specific Antigen [PSA] Importance of Health Screening Tests 

News A - Z


News Search

Medindia Newsletters

Subscribe to our Free Newsletters!

Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Find a Doctor

Stay Connected

  • Available on the Android Market
  • Available on the App Store

News Category

News Archive