Implicit gender bias has long been suspected in many medical
training programs, but until recently has been difficult to study
objectively. Now, for the first time, a nationally standardized
milestone evaluation system for emergency medicine residents is shining a
light on these potential biases.
In study published today in JAMA Internal Medicine,
researchers found that although male and female emergency medicine
specialists start off residency on an equal playing field, by the end of
the three-year training program male residents, on average, received
higher evaluations on all 23 emergency medicine training categories -
including medical knowledge, patient safety, team management, and
communication.
Distinct Gender Bias Found When It Comes to Expressing Anger
When men express their opinion with anger, people rate them as credible, but when women express identical arguments with anger, they are perceived as emotional.
Advertisement
‘Female residents in emergency medicine receive lower scores than males across all sub-competencies implicates bias rather than a deficit in specific skills or knowledge.’
Tweet it Now
During the first year of training, female residents actually scored slightly higher than males on 15 of the 23 areas, with notably higher scores in accountability, multitasking, and diagnosis. However, by the end of the third and final year of residency, males had gained higher scores in all 23 categories and had a 13% higher rate of milestone attainment per year - the equivalent of three to four months of additional training by graduation.
"We are concerned that the disparity we discovered in evaluations
may point to an implicit bias," said co-lead author Daniel O'Connor, a
student in the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of
Pennsylvania. "Our finding, that female residents in emergency medicine
receive lower scores than males across all sub-competencies really
implicates bias rather than a deficit in specific skills or knowledge."
![Save Girl Child! Every Unborn Child Should Be Welcomed Without Any Gender Bias]( "Save Girl Child! Every Unborn Child Should Be Welcomed Without Any Gender Bias")
Female feticide and infanticide is still widely prevalent across India. It is important that the society respects women and values their existence to stop killing girl child.
O'Connor and researchers from the University of Chicago Pritzker School of Medicine collected 33,456 "milestone" evaluations, from 359 emergency medicine residents over a two-year period. One-third (122) of the residents were female; two-thirds (237) were male. The training programs studied represent a mix of rural, suburban, and urban hospitals and included small, medium and large academic as well as community hospital programs.
About a third of the faculty physicians who evaluated the trainees were female (91) and two-thirds were male (194). Male and female faculty members evaluated residents similarly, consistently giving female residents lower scores throughout residency years two and three.
Although senior residents, for example, are expected to display stereotypically male characteristics such as assertiveness and independence, female residents who display such qualities may incur a penalty, even among their female role models, for violating customary gender roles.
"One way to interpret our findings is that a widening gender gap is attributable to the cumulative effects of repeated disadvantages and biases that become increasingly pronounced at the more senior levels of training," the authors wrote.
In light of recent national discussions calling for formalized competency demonstrations before residents can graduate in their specialty, this implicit bias could have long-term implications for female physicians.
"Based on our results," O'Connor said, "this would mean female residents could be required to complete additional training to graduate at the same level as their male counterparts."
Source: Eurekalert
Save Girl Child! Every Unborn Child Should Be Welcomed Without Any Gender Bias
Female feticide and infanticide is still widely prevalent across India. It is important that the society respects women and values their existence to stop killing girl child.
Advertisement
O'Connor and researchers from the University of Chicago Pritzker School of Medicine collected 33,456 "milestone" evaluations, from 359 emergency medicine residents over a two-year period. One-third (122) of the residents were female; two-thirds (237) were male. The training programs studied represent a mix of rural, suburban, and urban hospitals and included small, medium and large academic as well as community hospital programs.
About a third of the faculty physicians who evaluated the trainees were female (91) and two-thirds were male (194). Male and female faculty members evaluated residents similarly, consistently giving female residents lower scores throughout residency years two and three.
Although senior residents, for example, are expected to display stereotypically male characteristics such as assertiveness and independence, female residents who display such qualities may incur a penalty, even among their female role models, for violating customary gender roles.
"One way to interpret our findings is that a widening gender gap is attributable to the cumulative effects of repeated disadvantages and biases that become increasingly pronounced at the more senior levels of training," the authors wrote.
In light of recent national discussions calling for formalized competency demonstrations before residents can graduate in their specialty, this implicit bias could have long-term implications for female physicians.
"Based on our results," O'Connor said, "this would mean female residents could be required to complete additional training to graduate at the same level as their male counterparts."
Source: Eurekalert
Gender Bias of Prospective Parents
A new study has underlined the prevailing gender bias of prospective parents with men wishing for boys and women for girls.
Advertisement
 Study Reveals Gender Bias Found In Autoimmune DiseasesFemales can mount more powerful immune responses than males. Despite this, the flip side of this enhanced protection against infections is a greater risk for autoimmune disorders. | Advertisement
|
Advertisement
