Sighting Arsenic-Friendly Bacteria In Mono Lake Contested

Researchers claim foul over the finding by a young researcher in 2010 about bacteria in Mono Lake, California. In its place researchers are insisting that they were using phosphorus, a usual building block of living things, instead of arsenic compounds.

In 2010, a young researcher, Felisa Wolfe-Simon, published a paper in the journal Science, reporting that she and her colleagues had found bacteria in Mono Lake, Calif., that could be made to live on arsenic.

Arsenic in Drinking Water Increases Cardiovascular Disease Risk
High levels of arsenic exposure (>500 µg/L) in drinking water have been related to increased risks to cardiovascular diseases.

But now two papers have been published proving her wrong.

"We conclude that GFAJ-1 is an arsenate-resistant, but still a phosphate-dependent bacterium," ABC News quoted Tobias Erb and several fellow microbiologists in Zurich as writing.

Wolfe-Simon's paper drew international attention because it potentially broadened the definition of life as we know it, including life on other planets.

Scientists Discover Genetic Risk for Elevated Arsenic Toxicity
Genetic variants that elevate the risk for skin lesions in people chronically exposed to arsenic were found in one of the first large-scale genomic studies conducted in a developing country.

Living things, for all their complexity, are based on six elements - oxygen, carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, phosphorus and sulphur. Arsenic has chemical similarities to phosphorus, but it's toxic.

So the original Wolfe-Simon paper was explosive. But so was the response. Rosie Redfield of the University of British Columbia in Canada quickly answered with a blog post: "Basically, it doesn't present ANY convincing evidence that arsenic has been incorporated into DNA (or any other biological molecule)."

Groundwater Studies on Arsenic Levels in India
The most important tools in fieldwork on groundwater arsenic pollution in India are women and children armed with pamphlets and testing kits

Redfield was a co-author of one of the new papers. She and colleagues at Princeton University analyzed the work of Wolfe-Simon's team, and found it wanting.

"Mass spectrometry showed that this DNA contains only trace amounts of free arsenate and no detectable covalently bound arsenate," they concluded.

Solution to Remove Scourge of Arsenic Poisoning in South Asia Identified
Researchers at the Queen's University Belfast have come up with a solution to the world's worst case of ongoing mass poisoning by creating a new low-cost technology to provide arsenic-free

Wolfe-Simon later wrote an email to ABC News.

"There is nothing in the data of these new papers that contradicts our published data, which is also consistent with our current results. Our work continues to build upon our finding of extreme resistance to arsenate toxicity and the unexpected uptake of arsenate in the GFAJ-1 cells in the absence of added phosphate," she wrote.

The new studies have been published in Science.

Source-ANI