Medindia

X

Smoking Bans Won't Make Bars Restaurants Hand Out Pink Slips

by Tanya Thomas on  May 21, 2009 at 10:25 AM General Health News   - G J E 4
 Smoking Bans Won't Make Bars Restaurants Hand Out Pink Slips
If restaurant and bar owners have until now found shelter in the argument of job losses to oppose the smoking ban, an American study is out to prove otherwise.
Advertisement

Conducted in Minnesota, the study has shown that exempting bars from community smoking bans does not have any effect on the preservation of bar employment.

Advertisement
Study leader Elizabeth Klein, assistant professor of Health Behavior and Health Promotion at Ohio State University, has found that even the most comprehensive clean indoor air policies do not lead to a reduction in hospitality jobs.

She hopes that the findings of her study will factor into future debates within municipalities and states considering the economic and health issues surrounding smoking-ban proposals.

For their research, Elizabeth and her colleagues examined employment trends over three years in eight Minnesota cities with different types of clean indoor air policies and two cities with no laws restricting smoking.

The researchers revealed that of the policies examined by them, some were comprehensive bans prohibiting smoking in all workplaces, while others banned smoking in most public places and businesses, but exempted bars.

While previous studies have also evaluated economic effects of smoking bans in many individual communities, Elizabeth claims that her team's study is the first to compare the economic effects of different levels of clean indoor air policies in multiple cities.

"In the end we can say there isn't a significant economic effect by type of clean indoor air policy, which should give us more support for maintaining the most beneficial public health policies. The public health benefit clearly comes from a comprehensive policy where all employees are protected from exposure to environmental tobacco smoke," she said

"There is strong evidence that a comprehensive policy provides the greatest protection for all employees, and now it appears that bars do not need to be exempted from clean indoor air policies to protect against severe economic effects," she added.

A research article describing the study has been published in the June issue of the journal Prevention Science.

Source: ANI
TAN
Advertisement

Post your Comments

Comments should be on the topic and should not be abusive. The editorial team reserves the right to review and moderate the comments posted on the site.
User Avatar
* Your comment can be maximum of 2500 characters
Notify me when reply is posted I agree to the terms and conditions
Your headline, "Smoking bans won't make bars restaurants hand out pink slips" is completely incorrect: you read the press release on the study but you didn't read the study itself.

The authors very deliberately and specifically, right in line with their grant application for 516,568 dollars to produce the "right" results in their research for the antismoking group that funded it, did NOT examine bar employment separately from the 10x larger restaurant employment. In reality the bar industry was literally DECIMATED by the smoking bans in Minneapolis and St. Paul - the two largest and only named cities studied.

To see the full story behind it read Jacob Grier's May 27th column and the comments you will be disgusted. This "study" wasn't science: it was bought-and-paid-for politics pure and simple.

Michael J. McFadden,
Author of "Dissecting Antismokers' Brains"

MichaelJMcFadden Sunday, May 31, 2009

You May Also Like

Advertisement
View All