Registry of Donors to Address Ethical Concerns Over Organ Donations

by Gopalan on  September 5, 2007 at 12:17 PM Organ Donation News   - G J E 4
Registry of Donors to Address Ethical Concerns Over Organ Donations
Organ donations from living donors are looking up in the US. In 2004 and 2005, the number of such donations surpassed those from dead donors.

Many people risk surgery and the loss of an organ to save the lives of people they love — and increasingly of strangers, as well.

In addition to a kidney and lobe of a liver, living donors can give the lobe of a lung and bone marrow. Almost half of all kidney donors in the United States are living donors, a total of 6,434 last year.

Living donors last year also provided lobes of the liver to 288 recipients and lobes of a lung to five recipients. Transplants between unrelated donors are now highly successful, thanks to improved methods of immune suppression that reduce the need for close tissue matching to prevent rejection.

But many problems can complicate transplants from live donors. It is important that potential donors know about them and take the time to resolve them before deciding whether to go ahead with a donation, which carries the potential for serious physical and emotional risks.

Dr. Robert D. Truog, professor of medical ethics and anesthesia at the Harvard Medical School, says, "The possibilities include personality or emotional disturbances like depression, self-esteem, an abnormal desire for attention or a desire to become involved in the recipient's life."

But when the motive is suspect, transplant teams are supposed to assess the reasons and prohibit donations that raise serious concerns.

Recently, there has been an increase in organ donations directed to strangers who may advertise their need for transplants through the news media, the Internet and even on billboards. Although there is nothing illegal about soliciting a donor organ, the practice is inherently unfair and raises the possibility of buying and selling organs, which the medical community considers highly unethical. Donated organs are considered a "gift of life," not a commodity to be bought and sold.

There is a national list of people awaiting transplants, and those who are the sickest, though rarely the wealthiest, are at the top. But when donations are directed to strangers, potential recipients "who have the most compelling stories and the means to advertise their plight tend to be the ones who get the organs, rather than those most in need," Dr. Truog said.

There are other possible wrinkles in donations directed to strangers. The donor may insist that the donation not go to a recipient of a particular race, religion or ethnic group. One case, in which a white brain-dead donor specified that his organs go just to white recipients, prompted Florida to pass a law prohibiting patients and families from restricting donations in this way.

Another case was less clear-cut. A Jewish man in New York learned of a Jewish child in Los Angeles who needed a kidney and said he would donate a kidney to help this child. This is clearly a discriminatory donation, even though it would enable those below the child on the transplant list to move up a notch. On the other hand, if the donation was not allowed, no one would benefit, because the man would not offer his kidney to anyone else.

Pressure is mounting to establish a national registry of live donors, people who were willing to donate organs to relatives or friends but were not good matches.

Through such a registry, patients anywhere in the country could "swap" one of their donors who is not a match for a donor who is. Such programs have the potential to increase significantly the donor pool and the success of transplants, because the surgery can be done before the patient is deathly ill.

In recent years, small donor exchange programs have been established by the Johns Hopkins Medical Center, the New England Organ Bank and the Ohio Paired Donation Consortium.

Source: Medindia

Post your Comments

Comments should be on the topic and should not be abusive. The editorial team reserves the right to review and moderate the comments posted on the site.
User Avatar
* Your comment can be maximum of 2500 characters
Notify me when reply is posted I agree to the terms and conditions

You May Also Like

View All

More News on: