People living in the north of England are 20% more likely to die
before they reach 75 than those in the south, finds a study published on
An accompanying editorial says the north-south health divide
is now at its widest for 40 years and warns that "the north is being decimated
at the rate of a major city every decade."
The north-south health divide in England is well documented and has
posed a public health challenge - as well as a political and economic challenge
- to successive governments. From 2003 to 2010, the UK government had performance
targets for reducing geographical inequalities in health, but there has been
little research of time trends in this divide.
So, researchers at the University
of Manchester and Manchester City
Council set out to compare death rates between the north and south of England over
four decades. They analysed deaths and population data for all residents each
year from 1965 to 2008 from the five northernmost and four southernmost English
Their results show that overall rates of premature death
have been 14% higher in the north over the four decades. This inequality was
larger for men (15%) than for women (13%).
The north experienced a fifth more premature (under age 75)
deaths than the south, and this figure changed little between 1965 and 2008.
This north-south divide decreased significantly but
temporarily for both sexes from the early 80s to the late 90s, followed by a
steep rise from 2000 to 2008, despite government initiatives to reduce health
inequalities over this period.
Time trends also varied with age - most striking among the
20 to 34 age group, which saw a sharp rise (22%) in northern excess deaths from
1996 to 2008.
The large north-south divide has persisted despite the fact
that overall mortality in England has greatly reduced since 1965 - by about 50%
for men and about 40% for women with north and south both experiencing similar
"These findings point towards a severe, long-term and
recently worsening structural health problem in the geography of England, which
may not have received the attention it requires from government policy and
which has been resistant to specific policies to reduce inequalities in health
or regenerate local communities," said Professor Iain Buchan from the
University of Manchester School of Community Based Medicine and Mr John Hacking
from Manchester City Council's Joint Health Unit.
"More research is needed into: why policies to reduce such
inequalities have failed; how the wider determinants of health may be
unbalanced between north and south; and what role selective migration plays."
In an editorial also published today, Margaret Whitehead, Professor
of Public Health at the University of Liverpool, and Tim Doran, Clinical
Research Fellow at the University of Manchester warn that future prospects look
grim. They argue that deprived northern communities have "borne the brunt" of
the current recession and that government spending cuts "will also hit hardest
in the north."
They believe that the NHS must do more than pick up
the pieces and call for "a national overview" of access to NHS services for
different sections of the population living in different parts of the country.
"Otherwise, the result could be chaos and an even wider health divide."