Medindia

X

Orthopedic Surgeons Warn That Yoga can Harm Your Knees

by Dr. Trupti Shirole on  December 24, 2010 at 11:11 PM Alternative Medicine News   - G J E 4
Orthopedic surgeons have warned regular yoga followers that certain exercises can cause wear and tear of bone joints forcing them to undergo surgeries.
 Orthopedic Surgeons Warn That Yoga can Harm Your Knees
Orthopedic Surgeons Warn That Yoga can Harm Your Knees
Advertisement

According to Dr. Ashok Rajgopal, chairman of the Bone and Joint Institute in Medanta- The Medcity, extreme stretching exercises can cause severe stress on joints, leading to arthritis. He claims to have performed knee replacement surgery on several leading yoga gurus. His warning is a serious challenge to all the propagators of yoga who believe that yoga can ward off the effects of aging.

Advertisement
Dr. Rajgopal has explained that every time when a person performs deep knee bends he is actually dislocating the knee joints and this puts pressure on them. He has observed this among yogic gurus when they perform 'vajrasana'. Dr. Rajgopal says, "He has witnessed a higher incidence of bone ailments and joint ailments among yoga followers."

Source: Medindia
Advertisement

Post your Comments

Comments should be on the topic and should not be abusive. The editorial team reserves the right to review and moderate the comments posted on the site.
User Avatar
* Your comment can be maximum of 2500 characters
Notify me when reply is posted I agree to the terms and conditions
hello maamu, my personal experience is when I started doing Yog, I really feel better in my knee pain. yaar maamu, you must know that %wise more americans are doing yog than indians. please yaar stop working for MNCs..... and dont post this type of F..K..G articles.
jackel Wednesday, February 16, 2011
Hello, it seems to me that the orthopaedic surgeon does not even know the true meaning of yoga and its practices! First of all the term EXERCISES does not exist in the literature of YOGA and there is no way anybody can develop the conditions mentioned if one does it under proper guidance of a learned teacher. Yoga is a sequential progression of body-mind-spiritual concepts and only those who understand it stand to gain. With many scrupulous and sef proclaimed GURUS having a field day and the public at large following them blindly without even undertsanding the concepts it is no wonder that an orthopaedic surgeon has come out with such a suggestion!!! I sincerely request the general public and the orthopaedic surgeon to meet authentic Yoga practitioners and get to know the facts. We can quote references of people above the age of 80yrs upto the age of 95 and above who are still practising YOGA nd are hale and healthy!!! BEWARE anybody who comments useless stuff on YOGA - IT IS AN AUTHENTIC INDIAN TRADITION OF PHYSICAL-MENTAL-SPIRITUAL HEALTH AND ONLY PEOPLE WITH SUCH AN UNDERSTANDING CAN REALLY UNDERSTAND YOGA IN ITS COMPLETENESS.
anita Saturday, December 25, 2010
Stupid article posted just for the ads. Last paragraph starts with text from first one with MedIndia prefixed to it.
Akash123 Saturday, December 25, 2010
Could be true. I used to be a regular yogi and had experienced some kind of overstretching sensation that I could sense could break or loosen out my knee sometime. But, that s when your mind is not on track with the yoga your body is doing. Then for sure there's total uneasiness and stress on the joints. That's why you need expert supervision while doing yoga. Best wishes.
Achary Saturday, December 25, 2010
well it seems that the doc is saying by some observation... but if 'vajrasana' is so dangerous then the Chinese and Japanese people should have knee problem and will eventually go through knee surgery, but they are not. Yes extreme stretches are dangerous that is why one should not follow those after certain age, and I have not seen many of those kind of super stretching yogas in any ancient yoga books. ... I had chronic acidity, after taking long treatment from many docs[they usually prescribed famotidine and some other medicines], it way not alleviated. then I did pranayam and after 3 months of practice I got it right and it is not coming back any more. my dads blood pressure also fallowed the same trend. so doc plz do another study with neutral mind and some more parameters.
Shalima Friday, December 24, 2010

You May Also Like

Advertisement
View All