A recent paper published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B said that women who ate lots of breakfast cereal, salt and potassium were more likely to give birth to baby boys. But many are skeptical.
Conventional wisdom has it that it the male who determines the sex of offspring: If the man contributes a sperm bearing an X chromosome, then the embryo becomes female. A Y chromosome produces a male baby. It's a matter of chance. So the study, based on surveys with 740 pregnant women who were unaware of the sex of their babies, introduces a new twist to the story.
Statistician Stanley Young, who works for the National Institute of Statistical Sciences in Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, is disputing the findings.
"The biological reasoning didn't seem reasonable to me. And I looked at the statistics and it was complicated, but it didn't look reasonable either," says Young.
The author of the study, Fiona Mathews, says she understands Young's skepticism. "It's part of the scientific process," she notes. Yet she stands behind her statistical methods and her findings.
"The women who ate more (calories), including women who were more likely to eat cereal in the morning, were more likely to bear boys than girls," says Mathews. "And it's highly unlikely that this occurred by chance."
Mathews explains that a growing body of research into evolutionary biology has scientists asking new questions. They're trying to understand what happens to embryos in utero. Not all fertilized eggs make it to birth, so perhaps the mother's environment, diet or overall health does promote the survival of one gender over the other.
Despite the higher incidence of baby boys among women who had more potassium and sodium, Mathews says these are just correlations. It doesn't prove a cause-and-effect.
"The exciting thing is to try to work out which factors are the crucial ones and how they're working to influence the gender of the infant," she says.
Much more research is needed to untangle these questions. But Mathews says it's important for women to realize they can't use the results as a formula for making baby boys.
In her study, women who consumed the most calories had a 56 percent chance of having a boy. Those who ate the fewest calories had a 45 percent chance of giving birth to a boy.
Either way, it's close to 50-50 odds.
Young's criticisms of the study have been published in the Jan. 14 issue of Proceedings of the Royal Society B. He argues that Mathews and her colleagues may be wrong.
"It's hard to believe that woman can increase the likelihood of having a baby boy by eating more bananas, cereal or salt," Young told NPR radio.
After examining the data sets from the original study, which included questions about 132 food items, he says it's likely that the statistical significance with some of the foods including cereal and salt were simply due to chance. "It's essential that multiple testing be taken into account with transparent methods," Young says.