Statement By Robert Greenstein, on the New Reports From the Social Security and Medicare Trustees

Wednesday, March 26, 2008 General News
Email Print This Page Comment
Today's reports demonstrate again that policymakers will need to take action to shore up Social Security and Medicare finances, with the challenge being more modest in Social Security and more daunting in Medicare.



Social Security

The reports show that Social Security will be able to pay full benefits until 2041 and to pay 75 percent-78 percent of benefits after 2041, the year in which the program's trust funds will be exhausted. This year's estimates show some improvement over last year's; the Trustees' estimate of the size of the shortfall is about one-eighth smaller than last year's -- the largest improvement since 1983 -- largely as a result of changes in methodology and assumptions related to immigration.



Policymakers must restore Social Security's long-term solvency. But they do not need to make radical changes in the program's structure to do so. If they act in the coming years, a balanced package of relatively modest changes in both the program's revenues and its benefits, phased in gradually, can meet this goal. The longer they wait to act, however, the more painful the choices will become.



In addition, while Social Security's contribution to the nation's long-term fiscal problems is significant, we should not overstate it. If Congress makes permanent the 2001 and 2003 tax cuts without paying for them, the cost over the next 75 years will be about three times the size of the Social Security shortfall over this period.



Medicare

The issues facing Medicare are more challenging. The Medicare Hospital Insurance program's projected shortfall over the next 75 years is more than double the shortfall in Social Security, and Medicare's financing problems are much more difficult to solve. This is because Medicare's coming financial imbalances stem not from the nature of Medicare (or mainly from demographic pressures), but rather from the continuing sharp rise in health care costs throughout the U.S. health care system, in the public and private sectors alike. For the past 30 years, Medicare costs per beneficiary have risen at a nearly identical rate as health care costs per beneficiary systemwide.



As David Walker, until last week the Comptroller General, said, "[F]ederal health spending trends should not be viewed in isolation from the health care system as a whole. For example, Medicare and Medicaid cannot grow over the long term at a slower rate than cost in the rest of the health care system without resulting in a two-tier health care system ...."[1] Congressional Budget Office Director Peter Orszag has made similar points.



Policymakers cannot solve Medicare's problems in the absence of larger reform throughout the U.S. health care system that lowers costs to the extent possible and - in particular - slows the rate at which health care costs increase in the future. The needed reductions in projected Medicare costs cannot be achieved in isolation from changes that address health costs systemwide unless policymakers are willing to institute increasingly draconian cuts in health care for tens of millions of elderly and disabled Medicare beneficiaries who cannot afford to buy large amounts of supplemental health care on their own.



This does not mean that policymakers can or should do nothing to make changes in Medicare itself to restrain the program's costs. For example, federal policymakers have established an impressive expert advisory commission to advise them - the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC) - which has recommended an array of Medicare economies and efficiencies. Faced with intensive lobbying by the health insurance industry and other health care industry interests, however, Congress and the President have failed in recent years to enact many of MedPAC's recommendations.



Most egregious is their failure to adopt MedPAC's lo


Post your Comments

Comments should be on the topic and should not be abusive. The editorial team reserves the right to review and moderate the comments posted on the site.
* Your comment can be maximum of 2500 characters
I agree to the terms and conditions

News A - Z

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

News Search

Medindia Newsletters

Subscribe to our Free Newsletters!

Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

Press Release Category

Press Release Archive

Stay Connected

  • Available on the Android Market
  • Available on the App Store

Facebook